The Western Hemisphere:
An Introduction

I.       Introduction: Environment  (see map)

New World: only 13 percent of the world's population, but covers about 33 percent of its arable land. The United States receives as many immigrants each year as all other countries in the world combined. Nations of immigrants. Histories of colonialism.

Largest Countries in the World for
Land Area, Arable Land,
and Arable Land per capita

 

Total Land Area

Total Arable Land

Arable land per person

Hectares

1

Russia

USA

Australia

2.46

2

China

India

Canada

1.46

3

Canada

China

Kazakhstan

1.45

4

USA

Russia

Argentina

0.90

5

Brazil

Brazil

Russia

0.86

6

Australia

Australia

Lithuania

0.84

7

India

Canada

Latvia

0.78

8

Argentina

Argentina

Ukraine

0.67

9

Kazakhstan

Ukraine

Guyana

0.63

10

Algeria

Nigeria

USA

0.61

US Trade Partners

II.  Diversity and Community

A.  Region's share of world GDP is more than double its share of world population.

B.  Share of world exports is smaller than its share in world GDP. Large proportion of hemispheric trade is conducted within the United States.

C.  Dominance of United States: one-third of regional population, two-thirds of GDP, more than half of Latin American imports  and three-quarters of Canadian imports.

D.  Diversity of Latin America: size, wealth, ideology.

E.   Common features

1.   European Judeo-Christianity

2.   Only four major languages.

3.   Former colonies of England, Spain, France, Portugal.

4.   All independent by 1824. Spirit of independence—national holidays, histories of protectionism.

5.   Interaction of  native Americans, Europeans, Africans.

III. The United States: From
Protectionism to Liberalism

A.  18th Century protectionist statements by John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton, translated into trade barriers during 19th Century.

B.  Trade liberalization during early 20th Century (President Wilson) followed by extreme protectionism during Great Depression.

C.  Liberalization after 1934: Trade Agreements Act shifted authority to executive and provided for MFN clauses.

IV. Latin America: Liberalism to
Protectionism and Back

A.  After colonialism, initial liberalization of trade, esp. with England.

B.  Reaction to "big stick" of Teddy Roosevelt, seizure of the Panama Canal Zone in 1904. Price instability during 1920s, export collapse during Great Depression. Adopted programs of import-substitution during the early 1930s.

C.  After WWII, ISI advocated by Raul Prebisch and ECLA. Qualifications:

1.   Moderate tariffs and limited periods of protection

2.   ISI should be implemented on a regional basis.

D.  Beginning in 1970s, liberalizing factors:

1.   Poor performance of ISI.

2.   In 1973, General Pinochet and "Chicago Boys" in Chile.

3.   Pressure from IMF, World Bank after debt crisis.

V.  Economic Integration in the
Western Hemisphere

A.  Hemispheric Integration: Beginnings

1.            James G. Blaine, presidential nominee Secretary of State, proposed hemispheric customs union during  First International Conf. of the American States in 1889-90. Rejected by Argentina, still led to International Union of American Republics (IUAR) and, eventually, OAS.

Blaine

2.            Franklin D. Roosevelt renounced U.S. unilateral right of intervention in "good neighbor policy," but offset by Depression.

B.  Latin American Integration: The Troubled 1960s

1.            From late 1930s to 1959--Latin American desire for intra-regional integration opposed by U.S.

2.            Beginning in 1959, after Castro assumed power in Cuba, the U.S. supported common markets in Latin America with new Inter-American Development Bank. Early Latin efforts fell victim to political, military, and protectionist forces.

C.  The Alliance for Progress

Launched by Kennedy in 1961, ambitious goals for 1961-1971:

1.            Accelerate growth in every nation.

2.            Raise living standards of the poor.

3.            Eliminate adult illiteracy; primary education for all.

4.            Increase life expectancy; cut child mortality.

5.            Land and tax reform.

6.            Political liberty/democracy.

Some successes, important during 1962 Cuban missile crisis, but most goals were not fulfilled.

D.  ANCOM, CARICOM, and LAIA

Beginning in mid-1960s, Latin American leaders started new programs of regional integration:

1.Caribbean Community and Common Market (CARICOM).

2.Andean common market (ANCOM)

3.Latin American Integration Association (LAIA). Again, limited success.

E.   The Baker and Brady Debt Plans

1.Debt crisis in August 1982, Mexico unable to meet obligations. Led to 28 debt reschedulings.

2.Baker Plan in 1985—reforming countries should have access to new lending from banks and official agencies. Supported by World Bank, not by commercial bank.

3.Brady Plan in 1989—reforming countries acquire long-term credit at low interest rates by issuing bonds, with payment guaranteed by the IMF and the World Bank.

F.   Enterprise for the Americas

Launched in 1990 by U.S. President George Bush, set goals for:

1.            Hemispheric Free Trade, beginning with North America.

2.            IDB loans for privatization, market-oriented investments.

3.            Debt-for-nature swaps.

Again, performance fell short of rhetoric, but improved cooperation.

G.  The Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement (CUFTA)

Signed in 1988, was controversial in Canada.

1. Remove all remaining tariffs.

2. Reduce/eliminate non-tariff barriers in the energy, agricultural, and services.

Successfully implemented.

H.  From CUFTA to NAFTA

NAFTA presidential agreement in 1990, negotiations in 1991, preliminary agreement in 1992, ratified in 1993 (after U.S. elections and side agreements), and implementation began in 1994.

1.            Tariffs. Eliminate all tariffs over five, ten, and fifteen years.

2.            Rules of Origin. Generally, at least half the value of a qualified product must be derived from North American production.

3.            Investment. Mexico liberalizes foreign investments within ten years, and allows free repatriation of profits.

4.            Financial Services. U.S. and Canadian financial firms allowed to establish wholly owned subsidiaries in Mexico.

5.            Transportation. U.S. truckers can carry freight in Mexico.

6.            Dispute Settlement. North American Free Trade Commission, adjudicates broad disputes.

7.            The Environment. Environmental Secretariat should provide advice, and NADBank should finance projects along the U.S.-Mexico border.

8.            Labor Issues. Labor Council monitors compliance, resolves disputes, and promotes cooperation.

Evaluation: Arguments on both sides, but effect of NAFTA was small—especially for the United States.

I.    New Life for Latin American Integration

1.   In 1991, leaders of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, and Uruguay agreed to create a Common Market of the South (MERCOSUR). Agreed to quickly remove barriers against movement of goods, capital, and people, coordinate macroeconomic policies, establish a common external tariff, and create institutions for policy review and dispute resolution. In December 2013, Venezuela also became a full member of MERCOSUR, but it was suspended in December 2016 for failure to follow rules of the organization.

2.   In 1992, Colombia and Venezuela formed customs union and quickly dropped tariffs to zero. Trade doubled in one year, and, in 1994, included Mexico in the FTA.

 

J.   Free Trade Area for the Western Hemisphere (Americas) FTAA?

November 1994 - 34 countries agreed in principle to negotiate FTAA no later than 2005.

December 1994 - First Summit of the Americas in Miami, Florida

April 1998 - Second Summit of the Americas in Santiago, Chile, formally launched negotiations for FTAA. Negotiating Groups established for 12 topics (market access, investment, intellectual property rights, etc.)

April 2001 – 3rd Summit of the Americas, held in Quebec City with violent protests, was Pres. George W. Bush’s first summit meeting.  Leaders reaffirmed the 2005 goal and approved an action plan.

9/11/2001 – Initial sympathy toward the U.S. in response to terrorist acts, but eventual opposition to the war in Iraq from Canada, Mexico, Brazil (socialist government), and many other countries in the region.  Loss of momentum.

June 2003 – Comprehensive trade Agreement signed between U.S. and Chile. 85 percent of qualifying goods traded between the two countries became duty free; remaining tariffs would be phased out over the next 12 years. Between 2003 and 2015, US exports to Chile grew 474%, and imports from Chile grew 140%. Still, Chile is only our 28th largest goods trading partner.

November 2003 – 8th FTAA Ministerial
Meeting in Miami, reiterated aim to complete negotiations by 2005, but
that goal was not reached, and the U.S.  turned its attention to bilateral agreements--outside the FTAA.

J.   Creation of the South American Community in 2004, which    
      became UNASUR in 2008, with hopes of being a Latin
      version of the EU, and then Bancosur  in 2009.  These Latin
       efforts have been crippled by the financial problems in
       Venezuela, Brazil, and elsewhere.